A Tortured Soul



All photos by Ray Hydrick...except for this sad one above.

I have a confession.  I have never been a huge fan of raw tomatoes.  To hear of someone eating a tomato sandwich  – slices of ripe tomato on white bread with mayo, salt and pepper – sends me into a shutter and brings acid to the back of my throat.  Yes, I know…most lovers of the culinary arts go ga-ga over the fresh tomato taste, but I guess I have always been different.  Saute it for two minutes in olive oil, salt & pepper and then it is perfect.   Recently, though, something has changed. 

In my recent travels with work and play, I have been taunted to the depths of my foodie soul by one of the simplest of dishes – the Caprese Salad.  A salad made by layering sliced tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, drizzled with olive oil and maybe some balsamic vinegar.  This salad has lit a fire that I can’t contain.  Seriously, I would slit the tires of your grandma’s Hoverround to keep her from getting to this dish before I do.  I have no guilt in doing so…try me.  But I have noticed that my obsession for tomato-cheesy-basil goodness has spurned into making other dishes where the tomato (or its baby version – the cherry tomato) is the star.  Let’s look at a few. 

Caprese Salad with a Punch

I want to lick the screen right now

I would say that I came up with this twist because I discovered that the mozzarella presented in a Caprese Salad can sometimes be bland and tasteless, so I decided to make this dish with a mild goat cheese, but to be honest I forgot to buy mozzarella and I had goat cheese in the fridge.  Basically, it was a mischief moment turned golden.  Also, I decided I would like to take the basil a step further by making it into a basil-oil. 

1 vine ripe tomato
4 oz package goat cheese
Salt & Pepper

Since the slices of the tomato were larger than the goat cheese, I decided to half the slices to make them proportionate.  I then layered the slices between the rounds of goat cheese on a plate or platter.  (A quick tip:  slice your goat cheese when it is very cold, helps keep that round shape) Drizzle with basil oil (recipe below).  I served it with grilled or toasted slices of baguette. 

Basil Oil
1 cup basil leaves
1 clove garlic
1 scallion, chopped
1/3 cup olive oil
salt and pepper

Place the clove of garlic and scallion in a food processor or blender, chop till fine.  Add basil.  Turn on processor or blender and slowly drizzle oil in the mixture.  Add salt and pepper to taste.  You can certainly add more basil if you feel the oil is too thin. 

I used a mini-chopper but you can use full size or a blender

Tomato-palooza Continues…
To continue our Tomato-palooza, I made a quick quinoa salad with heirloom cherry tomatoes, purple basil, scallions and a quick lemon vinaigrette or heck, use that basil oil and add a couple of dashes of white balsamic vinegar.

Invited guest to my quinoa party


Just add and mix


I love quinoa!

Last but not least, I made a really quick panzanella salad using just toasted baguette (drizzled with olive oil, salt & pepper and toasted), heirloom cherry tomatoes, scallion, mixed greens, and basil oil with a splash of white balsamic vinegar. 

A few curls of parmesean cheese finishes off that panzanella off nicely


Panzanella salad served while grilled chicken...perfect light meal

My tomato torture has turned out to be good inspiration for some mischief.  But I still warn you to keep Grammy’s Hoverround out of my way…or you may even need to hide that tomato sandwich. 😉

5 Responses to “A Tortured Soul”

  1. rhbulldawg Says:

    My parents loved, LOVED raw tomato sandwiches, or raw tomatoes with salt… Dad even grew a TON of them in the back yard… I, somehow, never learned to love them either — until Kitchen Mischief started easing them into my meals!! Now, I love the taste (at least in smaller doses) 🙂

  2. Ritch Brandon Says:

    I LOVE tomatoes…and Caprese Salad is direct from the culinary gods. Glad you’ve come around. Love the blog, Matthew. I have you in my RSS feed and I’m going to share the love on FB with a link. ~Ritch

  3. Greg Says:

    A couple of years ago, someone I know was trying to be all high-falutin and served a Capri (!) salad made with so-so tomatoes, Kraft mozzarella cheese, and McCormick (yeah, dried) basil. Needless to say, it wasn’t impressive.

  4. Jennifer Mitchell Kline Says:

    Try the Caprese at the J. Clyde, next to the Blue Monkey. It is very good and served with a bit of yummy, specially fried okra.

  5. I’m Cuckoo for Quinoa! « Kitchen Mischief! Says:

    […] been cooking with it for years, and Matthew’s a fan — he shared a quinoa salad recipe years ago, and I alluded to its greatness in a post of my own starring avocado bisque. But these […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: